Who were the parents of Edgar R. Shaw of Musselshell Co., MT?

The Chitwood family was found on Ancestry World Tree  

What we knew
Vital Statistics Edgar was born January 18, 1889 somewhere in Ohio. He married Lottie Jackson in Musselshell Co., Montana in 1916.
Where we looked
1900 census
The every-name index for the 1900 census allowed us to search for Edgar without knowing the name of the head of household or even the county where he lived.

Just one Edgar Shaw appeared in the 1900 index for Ohio. He was born in January of 1889 and lived in Perry, Wood Co., Ohio. His father was Samuel Shaw, born in England. Samuel and his wife had been married just 4 years in 1900 so she was not the mother of our Edgar.

WWI draft cards
Edgar's WW I draft card gives his place of birth as Rising Sun, Ohio. This is in Wood county. His brother Freeman who appears with Edgar in 1900 and gives his birthplace as Fostoria, Ohio. This is in Seneca county.
Ohio marriages
The marriage records include Samuel Shaw and Amanda C. Miller marrying on Dec 13, 1884 in Seneca Co., Ohio    
1880 census
There is a Samuel Shaw of England living in Jackson Twp, Seneca Co., Ohio in 1880. He is living with a Miller family. No Amanda is in this family but there is an Amanda Miller on the previous page. 
What we learned
Family Tree We can feel confident that Samuel Shaw is the father of Edgar Shaw. Amanda Miller of Jackson Twp., Seneca Co., Ohio is a good candidate to be his mother. Additional research in Seneca and Wood counties, Ohio is recommended.

Got a pedigree puzzle? Get help from a professional researcher.